Prefer a downloadable PDF version? View the PDF case study (opens in a new tab).
A large health club could not reliably tell its members apart from its leads. It wanted to market to known, verified leads and suppress anyone who was, or had previously been, a member. FullContact resolved 19 million records to 9.4 million distinct people, which exposed how much of the spend was going to people the club already had.
Results at a Glance
- 80% reduction in marketing budget spent on leads
- Over $2 million saved annually
- 19 million records resolved to 9.4 million distinct people
- 29 million digital identities added to the member database
The Challenge
Membership businesses accumulate two files that describe overlapping populations and never quite reconcile. The lead file grows from every inquiry, form fill, guest pass, and promotion. The member file grows from everyone who joins. Nothing forces the two to agree, and the same person routinely appears in both, often several times over.
Health clubs have this worse than most, because membership is not a permanent state. People join, lapse, move locations, and rejoin. Each of those events can create a fresh record rather than update an existing one. Over time the lead file fills up with people who are already paying, and with people who used to pay and stopped.
The club wanted to market to known, verified leads, and to suppress anyone who was currently a member or had previously been one. The obstacle was not the marketing strategy, which was clear enough. It was that the underlying data could not answer the question the strategy depended on: is this person already ours.
The Approach
- Resolve everything to one person. FullContact unified more than 19 million records to a persistent PersonID and found 9.4 million distinct people behind them, meaning roughly half the records did not represent additional individuals at all.
- Expose the overlap. Resolution revealed significant overlap between the lead file and the member file, and significant duplication within each file separately. That overlap is the spend the club had been unable to see.
- Extend reach where it was still wanted. 29 million digital identities were added to the member database, providing incremental media reach for the campaigns that should still run.
The Results
Marketing budgets directed at leads were reduced by 80%, saving over $2 million annually.
Existing members were suppressed from acquisition campaigns, which produced better member experiences alongside the saving. And 29 million incremental touchpoints were added to the member database.
“Suppressing existing health club members from acquisition advertising is our number one marketing priority.” – CEO of Agency, National Health Club
Where This Applies
Any business where customers can lapse and return has this problem, and most of them do not know how large it is. Gyms and studios are the obvious case. Subscription services, telecom, insurance, associations, and season ticket holders all share the pattern: a customer file, a prospect file, and a population that moves between them without the systems noticing.
The lapsed customer is the part worth thinking hardest about. They are often the best prospects a business has, since they have already chosen you once. They are also the people most irritated by an offer addressed to strangers, because it demonstrates you have forgotten them. Suppressing them from acquisition is not the end of the conversation, it is the precondition for having a better one through a win-back campaign built for people you know.
Worth being precise about what produced the saving here. Nothing was cut from the marketing plan. The budget shrank because a large share of it had been reaching people the business already had, and resolution made that share visible for the first time.
Next Steps
Talk to us about separating your members from your leads.
Want to keep this resource handy? View the PDF case study (opens in a new tab).